Innerancy.

[Same Hakeem]

This is about the worst "contradiction" I've ever seen. You really need to up your game, Hakeem.

Indeed, it is the worst contradition I have seen where the Catholic Bible has 73 books while the Protestant 66 books. To make this contradition worse, the Greek Orthodox Bible 79 books. And all Bibles above claim to be inspired by God.

The fact is that all cannot be inspired by God if you have the originals of the above Bibles.

[One Bad Pig]

Indeed, it is the worst contradition I have seen where the Catholic Bible has 73 books while the Protestant 66 books. To make this contradition worse, the Greek Orthodox Bible 79 books. And all Bibles above claim to be inspired by God.

The fact is that all cannot be inspired by God if you have the originals of the above Bibles.

Hakeem, the Bible was not written as a unit. The books were written individually over a timespan of 1500 years or so, and not assembled as a unit for three centuries or so after the last one was written. You're making fundy atheists look competent by comparison, here.

[Cerebrum123]

Hakeem, the Bible was not written as a unit. The books were written individually over a timespan of 1500 years or so, and not assembled as a unit for three centuries or so after the last one was written. You're making fundy atheists look competent by comparison, here.

In my experience this is rather common with Muslims.

[Sparko]

In my experience this is rather common with Muslims.

If they had any sense or discernment they wouldn't be muslim.

[Same Hakeem]

Hakeem, the Bible was not written as a unit. The books were written individually over a timespan of 1500 years or so, and not assembled as a unit for three centuries or so after the last one was written. You're making fundy atheists look competent by comparison, here.

Thanks for the info. But the fact remains that all of these Bibles (Protestant 66 books, Catholic 73 books & Greek Orthodox 79 books) cannot be inspired by God.

[Cerebrum123]

Thanks for the info. But the fact remains that all of these Bibles (Protestant 66 books, Catholic 73 books & Greek Orthodox 79 books) cannot be inspired by God.

No that's not a fact. It's an assertion from your illogical mind.

[Same Hakeem]

No that's not a fact. It's an assertion from your illogical mind.

You may do this small task. And in case you do not do it, please check the following facts;

It is a fact that there are 73 books in the Catholic Bible. The Catholic Bible includes the following books that are not in the 66 books Protestant Bible:

1. Tobit,

2. Judith,

3-4. 1 & 2 Maccabees,

5. Ecclesiasticus,

6. Wisdom of Solomon, and

7. Baruch.

[KingsGambit]

What if a new sect of Muslims came around and decided that they would only recognize half of the Quran? Using your logic, this would mean the Quran is not inspired because there would be a disagreement on what constituted scripture.

[Same Hakeem]

What if a new sect of Muslims came around and decided that they would only recognize half of the Quran? Using your logic, this would mean the Quran is not inspired because there would be a disagreement on what constituted scripture.

I will not discuss Quran or any related matter to it here.

All these Bibles (i.e. Protestant 66 books, Catholic 73 books and Greek Orthodox 79 books) cannot be inspired fully by God even if we have the originals of each of these above referred Bibles.

[rogue06]

I will not discuss Quran or any related matter to it here.

Because doing so would expose that by the criteria that you are trying to establish the qur'an is not inspired by God.

Hypocrite.

[Cerebrum123]

What if a new sect of Muslims came around and decided that they would only recognize half of the Quran? Using your logic, this would mean the Quran is not inspired because there would be a disagreement on what constituted scripture.

[rogue06]

I'll add to this something I posted a few years ago:

(Itqan^[1]Al-Muhallaal-Kash-Shaf.

The ItqanItqanAl-MuhallaAl-Kashshaaf1.

[KingsGambit]

I
All these Bibles (i.e. Protestant 66 books, Catholic 73 books and Greek Orthodox 79 books) cannot be inspired fully by God even if we have the originals of each of these above referred Bibles.

Yes they can. You've provided no logical reason for that to be the case.

[Sparko]

You may do this small task. And in case you do not do it, please check the following facts;

It is a fact that there are 73 books in the Catholic Bible. The Catholic Bible includes the following books that are not in the 66 books Protestant Bible:

1. Tobit,

2. Judith,

3-4. 1 & 2 Maccabees,

5. Ecclesiasticus,

6. Wisdom of Solomon, and

7. Baruch.

https://answering-islam.org/Green/seven.htm

[rogue06]

https://answering-islam.org/Green/seven.htm

He refuses to discuss the implications that his position has on Islam

I will not discuss Quran or any related matter to it here.

Because doing so would expose that by the criteria that you are trying to establish the qur'an is not inspired by God.

Hypocrite.