March 6th 2012, 03:13 PM #1
Reason Rally: The Problems With New Atheism
Why is the Reason Rally not a threat?
The link can be found here
The text is as follows:
Why is the New Atheism not a threat? Let's talk about it on Deeper Waters.
The Reason Rally is largely a work of the new atheist movement. This has largely taken off after 9/11 with atheists seeking to have an even more prominent role in society. Mind you I have no problem with that. Atheists have as much right as anyone else to seek to change the laws to be in accordance with what they think is best and they have every right to state their views publicly, meet publicly, etc.
The problem is not that they are doing this. In reality, I do not see the new atheists as a problem. Rather, I see them as a blessing in much the same way The Da Vinci Code was. The Da Vinci Code started a conversation and Christians who were interested would better inform themselves about the truths of what it is they believe. I believe the New Atheists have done the same thing. They've made the dialogue public.
However, the blessing is not only have they made the dialogue public, but they have not presented a very strong case and one that a series at any church that was led by someone skilled in apologetics could train someone to answer. Due to their being seen as authorities, they are taken far more seriously and leading many atheists to think this is the cream of the crop.
If it is, then the crop has gone very bad. Dawkins, the leading speaker of the new atheism is not qualified in philosophy or theology or biblical studies to speak on any of these matters, but does so anyway. The atheist thinking "The God Delusion" presents sound arguments, walks away thinking, as an example, that the Thomistic arguments are easily dealt with.
That is, until he meets a Thomist who knows those arguments.
At that point, the atheist sadly usually does not see the flaws in the arguments, but instead still holds to them because, well Pope Dawkins has spoken and the case is closed. The reality is Dawkins could go to anyone out there who studies Thomism and be told that his positions are straw men and the arguments he has do not work.
Furthermore, with the high interest in science, we can expect to see more of scientism from the new atheist side. No Christian should be anti-science, but we should all be anti-scientism. We need to realize that there are other forms of finding truth out there and for most of us, the most important truths we know are not scientific in nature.
The benefit for us is this verificationism is easily dealt with. As I have stated earlier, for an atheist like this, science for them is essentially what Scripture is for the Christian. Instead of having Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John, we have Dawkins, Harris, Dennett, and quite likely we can expect Meyers to be next in line.
With Dawkins being a leading speaker at this rally, we can expect more of the same. What this will do is just lead to further reinforcement. Just as much as Christians can cloister themselves away from the world at times in isolation to reinforce one another in beliefs that they hold without evidence, atheists can do the same. This is not to say all Christians believe without evidence. I certainly don't and several others don't. This is to say that there are several who do. There are several atheists of the Dawkins type who also hold their anti-religious beliefs without evidence.
Thus, not only do I think the Reason Rally is not really a threat, but it will also be a boon to Christians. If atheists want to keep availing themselves of material by the new atheists, we can expect that their side will ultimately suffer. Let us not make the same mistake however of growing lax in our efforts and make sure the sources we have and the ones we choose to have represent us are the best that they can be.
What atheists need to do is in fact distance themselves from meetings like the Reason Rally and to avoid the new atheists. They are better off going to older atheists of the past. Not only that, they need to make sure that they avail themselves of evangelical scholarship so they can be sure they know what their opponents are really arguing.
If atheists want to still go to this rally, please do go ahead. The more I see there, the more hope I will have for the spread of Christianity.
Nick PetersCheck the blog of Apologiaphoenix!
Support Deeper Waters Christian Ministries!
The following tWebber says Amen to ApologiaPhoenix for this useful Post:
By ApologiaPhoenix in forum Deeper WatersReplies: 6Last Post: March 13th 2012, 12:22 PM
By ApologiaPhoenix in forum Deeper WatersReplies: 0Last Post: March 5th 2012, 04:33 PM
By ApologiaPhoenix in forum Deeper WatersReplies: 0Last Post: March 3rd 2012, 07:11 PM
By ApologiaPhoenix in forum Deeper WatersReplies: 2Last Post: March 3rd 2012, 11:54 AM
By ApologiaPhoenix in forum Deeper WatersReplies: 4Last Post: February 29th 2012, 01:01 AM