Do you believe in zombies?

[Sparko]

Where is the wind?

or where is the number 2?

[JimL]

or where is the number 2?

When are you going to tell us where the soul is? Where is your soul/spirit right now Sparko? I don't think you have any clue how to answer that, any of you.

[Tassman]

Your opinion is duly noted.

There is no verifiable evidence to support the existence of souls. They can be reduced to the neurological function of the brain and nervous system.

Where is the wind?

The "wind" is air in natural motion...it is measurable and it's its existence is not in doubt. Unlike the hypothesis of the 'soul'!

[One Bad Pig]

There is no verifiable evidence to support the existence of souls. They can be reduced to the neurological function of the brain and nervous system.

Not verifiably.

[Tassman]

Not verifiably.

Or to put it another way, the notion of 'souls' is a failed hypothesis

[Teallaura]

When are you going to tell us where the soul is? Where is your soul/spirit right now Sparko? I don't think you have any clue how to answer that, any of you.

What I was getting at is that prepositions don't have meaning when talking about the interaction of the material and the immaterial. We use them out of convention, not literal meaning. A soul and body go together - but you're asking how a ten dimensional body interacts with a two dimensional one - there's no frame of reference to give the kind of answer you're looking for. And that's in large part an error on your part - you're applying your worldview to ours. They don't mesh - cannot mesh - because the materialist view you take is contrary to the Christian view that there is more than the material universe.

Which only proves that one has to be false - it doesn't tell us anything about which one that is.

[Sparko]

When are you going to tell us where the soul is? Where is your soul/spirit right now Sparko? I don't think you have any clue how to answer that, any of you.

I already told you. It is in the left little toe. Don't you bother to read?

[JimL]

What I was getting at is that prepositions don't have meaning when talking about the interaction of the material and the immaterial. We use them out of convention, not literal meaning. A soul and body go together - but you're asking how a ten dimensional body interacts with a two dimensional one - there's no frame of reference to give the kind of answer you're looking for. And that's in large part an error on your part - you're applying your worldview to ours. They don't mesh - cannot mesh - because the materialist view you take is contrary to the Christian view that there is more than the material universe.

Which only proves that one has to be false - it doesn't tell us anything about which one that is.

We are talking about the material universe, more to the point we are talking about the material body, within the which christians claim there to exist a spirit or soul. If the preposition has no meaning, then what exactly do you mean? It seems to me that what you're all saying is that it makes no sense, we can't explain it, but we just believe it anyway.

[JimL]

I already told you. It is in the left little toe. Don't you bother to read?

Yes, you've already made it perfectly clear that you have no idea what you're talking about Sparko

[Sparko]

Yes, you've already made it perfectly clear that you have no idea what you're talking about Sparko

I don't know what I am talking about? Look in the mirror buddy.

OK sure the soul is not actually in the little toe. I just made that up. But JimL, NO CHRISTIAN is going to tell you, an atheist where the soul is. It a very closely held church secret. If people like you knew where the soul is, all Christians would be vulnerable. You atheists could go around stealing our souls and holding them hostage.

[Christianbookworm]

I don't know what I am talking about? Look in the mirror buddy.

OK sure the soul is not actually in the little toe. I just made that up. But JimL, NO CHRISTIAN is going to tell you, an atheist where the soul is. It a very closely held church secret. If people like you knew where the soul is, all Christians would be vulnerable. You atheists could go around stealing our souls and holding them hostage.

Uh, right! Yeah, closely guarded secret. Isn't it the same place where the Holy Spirit indwells us believers?

[JimL]

I don't know what I am talking about? Look in the mirror buddy.

OK sure the soul is not actually in the little toe. I just made that up. But JimL, NO CHRISTIAN is going to tell you, an atheist where the soul is. It a very closely held church secret. If people like you knew where the soul is, all Christians would be vulnerable. You atheists could go around stealing our souls and holding them hostage.

Like I said Sparko, you have no clue. No need to keep telling us that.

[Christianbookworm]

Jimmy has no clue!

[JimL]

Jimmy has no clue!

That's true, that's why I'm asking you christians, but it seams you have no clue either. Apparently it's just a bunch of nonsense.

[Sparko]

Uh, right! Yeah, closely guarded secret. Isn't it the same place where the Holy Spirit indwells us believers?

Shush!!!! Don't tell him!