Nobody Dies for a Lie

[seer]

We haven't burned you yet.

An oversight?

[JimL]

Quite.

smug superiority.

[JimL]

JimL. So you are just going to handwave away everything and repeat yourself as I knew you would. You like to complain that nobody takes the time to explain their beliefs to you and show you how you are mistaken when we claim you have it all wrong. So I did. I gave you a line by line logical layout of what the trinity is, why we believe it and where it is taught in the bible.

Your response was "duh! you said it was hard to understand! that proves I wuz right!"

Saying that the Trinity is logical doesn't make it logical, Sparko. It isn't logical, it's completely illogical, and if you can't see that then you don't even understand what logic is. And no, my response was that "it's hard to understand because it doesn't make any sense whatsoever." You have 2 choices, you can either recognize it for the illogical nonsense that it is, or you can continue believe it because that's what you've been taught.

[Cow Poke]

Saying that the Trinity is logical doesn't make it logical, Sparko. It isn't logical, it's completely illogical, and if you can't see that then you don't even understand what logic is. And no, my response was that "it's hard to understand because it doesn't make any sense whatsoever." You have 2 choices, you can either recognize it for the illogical nonsense that it is, or you can continue believe it because that's what you've been taught.

Those are not the only two choices, except to a very limited mind.

[Sparko]

Saying that the Trinity is logical doesn't make it logical, Sparko. It isn't logical, it's completely illogical, and if you can't see that then you don't even understand what logic is. And no, my response was that "it's hard to understand because it doesn't make any sense whatsoever." You have 2 choices, you can either recognize it for the illogical nonsense that it is, or you can continue believe it because that's what you've been taught.

It is logical. I laid out the logic for you, piece by piece. There is no contradiction. Yet your response is simply to hand wave it away and repeat yourself. You haven't gone through one bit of my post to show me where the logic fails. And I don't believe it because that was what I was taught. I already told you I did NOT believe it at first and did my own research on it and that article is the result of what I discovered.

Your dismissal without any actual rebuttal on any point is therefore dismissed itself. You are a low intelligence moron who thinks he is a genius. It's pretty sad to watch. Maybe you should stop posting drunk or whatever the hell is going on.

[Zymologist]

Saying that the Trinity is logical doesn't make it logical, Sparko. It isn't logical, it's completely illogical, and if you can't see that then you don't even understand what logic is. And no, my response was that "it's hard to understand because it doesn't make any sense whatsoever." You have 2 choices, you can either recognize it for the illogical nonsense that it is, or you can continue believe it because that's what you've been taught.

Saying that the Trinity is illogical doesn't make it illogical.

QED

[JimL]

It is logical. I laid out the logic for you, piece by piece. There is no contradiction. Yet your response is simply to hand wave it away and repeat yourself. You haven't gone through one bit of my post to show me where the logic fails. And I don't believe it because that was what I was taught. I already told you I did NOT believe it at first and did my own research on it and that article is the result of what I discovered.

Your dismissal without any actual rebuttal on any point is therefore dismissed itself. You are a low intelligence moron who thinks he is a genius. It's pretty sad to watch. Maybe you should stop posting drunk or whatever the hell is going on.

Your so called logic is that the idea of the trinity comports with certain passages in the bible itself, not that it comports with logic, you dope. We're discussing the logic of the trinity in and of itself, not whether or not it comports with certain passages in the bible. The idea of the trinity is an illogical idea whether you can find passages in the bible that you think supports the trinitarian view or not.

[JimL]

Saying that the Trinity is illogical doesn't make it illogical.

QED

That's true, which is why I pointed out how it was illogical. Not that I should have to point out something so obvious.

[Sparko]

Saying that the Trinity is illogical doesn't make it illogical.

QED

It doesn in Jimmyworld. He just has to repeat himself enough times and it magically becomes true. For him at least.

[Sparko]

Your so called logic is that the idea of the trinity comports with certain passages in the bible itself, not that it comports with logic, you dope. We're discussing the logic of the trinity in and of itself, not whether or not it comports with certain passages in the bible. The idea of the trinity is an illogical idea whether you can find passages in the bible that you think supports the trinitarian view or not.

So show me how it is illogical instead of just repeating that it is.

[Sparko]

That's true, which is why I pointed out how it was illogical. Not that I should have to point out something so obvious.

you didn't. you just kept saying it was.

[Cow Poke]

That's true, which is why I pointed out how it was illogical.

Actually, you just called a dog's tail a leg, and claimed you had a five legged dog.

[One Bad Pig]

smug superiority.

Well, no. Every once in a while, you actually put some effort into your posts. You're much more interesting to interact with when you do. Please consider doing so more often.

[Tassman]

Saying that the Trinity is illogical doesn't make it illogical.

But it is illogical though. The deity cannot be logically 'one' and yet consist of three persons, unless he suffers from a 'multiple personality disorder'. The same applies to the absurd Christology of the Hypostatic Union, i.e. Jesus being fully god and fully man at one and the same time.

[37818]

That's true, which is why I pointed out how it was illogical. Not that I should have to point out something so obvious.

jim,

What do you understand is the difference between being a person and being a god?