There is no such thing as a former Christian. - Page 2 - TheologyWeb Campus
TheologyWeb Campus TheologyWeb Campus


Hello and welcome to TheologyWeb – theology debate with a serious dose of fun! It has been our goal to create one of the best and most innovative discussion sites on the Net. Please visit our forums where we debate and discuss everything from religion, politics, lifestyle, pop culture, to who is the coolest member of the moderating team. Register now and join in the fun, its free, easy, and makes Dee Dee Warren happy.




*This site is best viewed in Mozilla Firefox with a minimum display resolution of 1024x768.

Reply

There is no such thing as a former Christian.
View First Unread
Jedidiah is online now
Jedidiah TheologyWeb Grandfather
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 7,292
Join Date: August 1st, 2003
Spam: 9921 | Anti-Spam: 277
Pearls: 574
 
Old
  September 16th 2009 , 08:53 PM
 
In reply to this post by JAYMZ
 
 
 
2 Timothy 2:11-13
Your point?

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
He has showed you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Jedidiah is online now
Jedidiah TheologyWeb Grandfather
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 7,292
Join Date: August 1st, 2003
Spam: 9921 | Anti-Spam: 277
Pearls: 574
 
Old
  September 16th 2009 , 08:56 PM
 
 
 
 
[quote=Seasanctuary;2780295]How does a person who believes she is a Christian determine she really is a Christian as opposed to only thinking she is a Christian?

Why does she think she is a Christian?

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
He has showed you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
SlapShot is offline
SlapShot tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Undisclosed  |  Mountain  |  Hideaway  
Posts: 252
Join Date: January 7th, 2007
Spam: 14 | Anti-Spam: 21
Pearls: 480
 
Old
  September 16th 2009 , 09:03 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
Most of the atheists I know are apostates as well.
What's hard to believe about that? People change their religious beliefs all the time. Jews, Hindus, and Muslims convert to Christianity and I see nobody doubting them.
I hope we're not talking about the no true scotsman fallacy.

 
    Quiner Member tWebber  
     
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Seasanctuary is offline
Seasanctuary Magna Cum Laude
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Agnostic  |  Independent  
Posts: 8,346
Join Date: December 30th, 2003
Spam: 467 | Anti-Spam: 1824
Pearls: 530
 
Old
  September 16th 2009 , 09:12 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
Why does she think she is a Christian?
* Believes the Gospel.
* Sincerely credits and praises God.
* Wants to stop sinning.

 
  Alumnus of the Month: AotM vote winner - Issue reason: September 2004 Alumnus    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
JAYMZ is offline
JAYMZ tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 827
Join Date: January 24th, 2009
Spam: 0 | Anti-Spam: 156
Pearls: 210
 
Old
  September 16th 2009 , 09:21 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
From a christian perspective, something actually true takes place ( between God and man ) when someone repents from their sins and puts their faith in christ.
Most christians believe that someone with true saving faith will never go on latter to deny Christ. ( or God for that matter )

If this does happen, maybe that person just had a " said " faith instead of true heart felt faith.

We need to make a distinction between a one time emotional experience and true repentance.
Ultimately only God knows those who are His.

 
    tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Anon is online now
Anon Roots for the seed-pickers
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Agnostic  |  Libertarian  
Posts: 558
Join Date: September 23rd, 2008
Spam: 44 | Anti-Spam: 117
Pearls: 361
 
Old
  September 16th 2009 , 09:31 PM
 
In reply to this post by JAYMZ
 
 
 
Ultimately only God knows those who are His.
There are passages where Paul, I think, address his audience so that they may be assured, or somesuch. There are self-tests ready in the Bible, like I John, that guarantee that salvation can be assured via conscience and conviction of the Spirit.

 
  Letterman: gym debate particpant - Issue reason: debate warrior:  it is reasonable to believe that the Christian God exists.    tWebber  
     
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Sheepdog is offline
Sheepdog is caught in the Matrix. Swindling the next generation.
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 12,443
Join Date: February 6th, 2003
Spam: 9832 | Anti-Spam: 2900
Pearls: 1032
 
Old
  September 16th 2009 , 11:54 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
It's the ultimate OSAS cop out. let's say there is an atheist who claims he was a born again Christian. the Calvinist, etc., can simply shrug him off, unjustifiably, as one who was not a true Christian in the first place.

It's a play of the "No True Scotsman" fallacy, really.

 
  Letterman: gym debate particpant - Issue reason: he's a real deep god Alumnus of the Month: AotM vote winner - Issue reason: July 2004 Alumnus    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Carrikature is online now
Carrikature of the Alps
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Yodelling  |  Veterinarian  
Posts: 643
Join Date: May 15th, 2009
Spam: 387 | Anti-Spam: 216
Pearls: 225
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 01:11 AM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
a) they were never truly saved
I added the rest of the answer so it'd be clearer what I was answering.

By the time I've gotten around to answering this, it seems it's been pretty well covered by others. The difficulty, of course, lies in presuming you can know the true state of someone's soul pre-deconversion. There are those that go through this process because they are fed misinformation and remain unaware. When the truth comes out, they feel betrayed. It is a regrettable occurence, but one that is not linked to the actuality of someone's salvation. If they never were truly saved, it's potentially better that they deconvert.

 
    tWebber  
     
This is a song for your bear-trapped teddy.
He looks uncomfortable, think I'd be too.
But with this song, for your bear-trapped teddy.
He will feel better, in a day or two.
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Moksha is offline
Moksha poltergeist
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Quaker  |  Dystopian  
Posts: 228
Join Date: May 6th, 2009
Spam: 413 | Anti-Spam: 14
Pearls: 200
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 02:07 AM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
This is an old topic, but I have not seen any really new topics, but reading the Victor Stenger thread got me going on it again. According to my understanding of the Bible there can not be former Christians. Those who make such a claim are fooling themselves.
I presume you take that understanding from Paul?
That may be his understanding but it's not mine nor many other ex-christians experience.

 
    tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
technomage is offline
technomage (Mostly) Off the net
Currently Unavailable
 
Undisclosed  |  Wiccan  |  -  
Posts: 13,463
Join Date: October 22nd, 2004
Spam: 68 | Anti-Spam: 440
Pearls: 541
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 07:29 AM
 
In reply to this post by Jaecp
 
 
 
There are plenty of former christians, theological claims that we were never really christians accomplishes what Jeb?
It gives theological authority to a "no true Scotsman" argument, which makes the argument unimpeachable in the mind of the arguer.

 
  Alumnus of the Month: AotM vote winner - Issue reason: September 2005 Alumnus and winsome groveler    Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Jaecp is online now
Jaecp Servant of Necoho
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  JEDI!  |  Jadiestic  
Posts: 1,795
Join Date: May 15th, 2008
Spam: 0 | Anti-Spam: 793
Pearls: 210
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 07:38 AM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
Well, yeah,

I was hoping he'd give me more than that. I'm familiar with the line of reasoning that any christian whod leave obviously wasnt a real christian in the first place. I've had it leveled at me before.

 
    tWebber  
     
In the name of all that is good and holy O Jaecp, we ask that you henceforth write your posts in English, for the sake of the ignorant. -ApologiaPhoenix
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
technomage is offline
technomage (Mostly) Off the net
Currently Unavailable
 
Undisclosed  |  Wiccan  |  -  
Posts: 13,463
Join Date: October 22nd, 2004
Spam: 68 | Anti-Spam: 440
Pearls: 541
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 07:48 AM
 
In reply to this post by Jaecp
 
 
 
I was hoping he'd give me more than that.
There's nothing more to give--but from the believer's view, there doesn't need to be any more.

 
  Alumnus of the Month: AotM vote winner - Issue reason: September 2005 Alumnus and winsome groveler    Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
headheart is offline
headheart Disciple
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Disciple of  |  Jesus Christ  
Posts: 3,069
Join Date: October 3rd, 2006
Spam: 79 | Anti-Spam: 1344
Pearls: 55
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 08:36 AM
 
wink
In reply to this post by Matt M
 
 
 
Why is it that the wolf howls in the moonlight?
all_His_children.jpg

It is calling to its brothers and sisters.

Owoooooooooooooooooo___________________!

We had better hurry now and run to our howling brothers and sisters and remind them that they are family.

Owoooooooooooooooooo____________________!
HH.

 
    Quiner Member tWebber  
     
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 

The following tWebber says Amen to headheart for this useful Post:
Jedidiah is online now
Jedidiah TheologyWeb Grandfather
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 7,292
Join Date: August 1st, 2003
Spam: 9921 | Anti-Spam: 277
Pearls: 574
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:09 PM
 
In reply to this post by SlapShot
 
 
 
Most of the atheists I know are apostates as well.
What's hard to believe about that? People change their religious beliefs all the time. Jews, Hindus, and Muslims convert to Christianity and I see nobody doubting them.
I hope we're not talking about the no true scotsman fallacy.
The no true scotsman fallacy need not be a fallacy at all. If there is a specific definition for a scotsman, anyone who fails that definition is no true scotsman.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
He has showed you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Jedidiah is online now
Jedidiah TheologyWeb Grandfather
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 7,292
Join Date: August 1st, 2003
Spam: 9921 | Anti-Spam: 277
Pearls: 574
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:10 PM
 
 
 
 
* Believes the Gospel.
* Sincerely credits and praises God.
* Wants to stop sinning.
Misses the mark. A Christian trusts the Gospel, not just believes it is true.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
He has showed you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
themuzicman is offline
themuzicman Are they flying yet?
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 36,699
Join Date: March 6th, 2003
Spam: 43745 | Anti-Spam: 6060
Pearls: 658
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:13 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 

 
  Department Head: is somewhat mighty! - Issue reason: looking for flying pigs Alumnus of the Month: AotM vote winner - Issue reason: June 2008 Alumnus Letterman: gym debate particpant - Issue reason: debate warrior    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
The Rental Car Review!
Open Theists! Join your Facebook group!
Blue Blood Republicans are losers.
Obama - One Bad Apple Mistake, America
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 

« Previous Thread   |   Post New Thread   |   Next Thread »


 
Forum Jump  

Page generated in 0.40782 seconds with 15 queries