Atheism, Theism And Abortion - TheologyWeb Campus
TheologyWeb Campus TheologyWeb Campus


Hello and welcome to TheologyWeb – theology debate with a serious dose of fun! It has been our goal to create one of the best and most innovative discussion sites on the Net. Please visit our forums where we debate and discuss everything from religion, politics, lifestyle, pop culture, to who is the coolest member of the moderating team. Register now and join in the fun, its free, easy, and makes Dee Dee Warren happy.




*This site is best viewed in Mozilla Firefox with a minimum display resolution of 1024x768.

Reply

Atheism, Theism And Abortion
View First Unread
seer is offline
seer tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 14,079
Join Date: April 20th, 2003
Spam: 13 | Anti-Spam: 4526
Pearls: 733
 
Old
  August 5th 2003 , 09:08 PM
 
 
Last edited by seer : August 5th 2003 at 09:51 PM .  
 
 
I have run in pro-life circles for 14 years now. And in that time I have only met a handfull of atheists - about 5. The vast majority of pro-lifers are either christian, muslim, or orthodox jews. Now when it comes to the practical application of one's ethics why is it that the theists are the ones trying to save innocent human lives, and the atheists who don't seem to care?

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
"He who learns must suffer. And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God." Aeschylus
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
LGM is offline
LGM is caught in the Matrix. is caught in the Matrix.
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Somewhat  |  Unorthodox  
Posts: 8,925
Join Date: May 14th, 2003
Spam: 949 | Anti-Spam: 4359
Pearls: 880
 
Old
  August 5th 2003 , 10:37 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
I have been reading about the Catholic Church for quite sometime now. And in that time I have never heard of an atheist Priest or Bishop. The vast majority of Catholic Priests are, well Catholic. And they are thoroughly trained Christian theologians (much more so than Seer), who have to pass a rigorous review before they are ordained. Now when it comes to the practical application of one's ethics why is it that so many countless Priests have raped and sexually molested children, and then intimitated them to keep them quiet, and had their transgressions covered up by their stonewalling Bishops? Why are so few in jail and why are the victims paid off with the hard earned donations of their congregations?

LGM
...just imagining the lucky atheist who got to stand next to Seer with his bullhorn and "Burn in Hell" placard at his last pro-life rally...

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Vorkosigan is offline
Vorkosigan tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
 
Posts: 2,392
Join Date: February 25th, 2003
Spam: 37 | Anti-Spam: 820
Pearls: 539
 
Old
  August 5th 2003 , 10:47 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
Now when it comes to the practical application of one's ethics why is it that the theists are the ones trying to save innocent human lives, and the atheists who don't seem to care?

Do you have any solid evidence to show that atheists don't care about saving lives? You know, that Buddhists, Confucians, pantheists, etc just don't care?

Vorkosigan

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
People are the only mirror we have to see ourselves in. The domain of all meaning. All virtue, all evil, are contained only in people. There is none in the universe at large. Solitary confinement is a punishment in every human culture. -- LM Bujold
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Piebald is offline
Piebald tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 8,756
Join Date: January 27th, 2003
Spam: 7784 | Anti-Spam: 675
Pearls: 700
 
Old
  August 5th 2003 , 11:08 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
Actually there are Atheists for Life.

Also remember that America is like 90% theist... and abortion is still legal here.

 
  Alumnus of the Month: AotM vote winner - Issue reason: May 2005 Alumnus Alumnus of the Year: AotY vote winner - Issue reason: 2004 Alumnus of the Year    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
AtheistArchon is offline
AtheistArchon "Forget" the president.
Currently Unavailable
 
 
Posts: 5,130
Join Date: March 13th, 2003
Spam: 674 | Anti-Spam: 1189
Pearls: 817
 
Old
  August 5th 2003 , 11:27 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
- Ehhh...

why is it that the theists are the ones trying to save innocent human lives, and the atheists who don't seem to care?
- This is pretty much the standard anti-choice line. "Innocent human lives"... well define "life". Do you mean a cluster of cells without the capacity for thought? Or do you mean a human being? There's a tremendous difference.

 
  Letterman: gym debate particpant - Issue reason: friend of cats    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
BeHereNow is offline
BeHereNow edible rapper
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Atheist  |  Libertarian  
Posts: 5,168
Join Date: June 28th, 2003
Spam: 1489 | Anti-Spam: 1122
Pearls: 345
 
Old
  August 5th 2003 , 11:34 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
Today @ 02:08 AM post located here
seer:


Now when it comes to the practical application of one's ethics why is it that the theists are the ones trying to save innocent human lives, and the atheists who don't seem to care?
Nice loaded question, Seer.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
The rain, it started tapping on the window near my bed.
There was a loophole in my dreaming, so I got out of it.
And to my surprise my eyes were wide and already open.
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
seer is offline
seer tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 14,079
Join Date: April 20th, 2003
Spam: 13 | Anti-Spam: 4526
Pearls: 733
 
Old
  August 6th 2003 , 06:26 AM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
Do you have any solid evidence to show that atheists don't care about saving lives? You know, that Buddhists, Confucians, pantheists, etc just don't care?
I do know Buddists that are strongly pro-life. Are you pro-life Vorkosigan? How many atheist here are pro-life?

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
"He who learns must suffer. And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God." Aeschylus
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
seer is offline
seer tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 14,079
Join Date: April 20th, 2003
Spam: 13 | Anti-Spam: 4526
Pearls: 733
 
Old
  August 6th 2003 , 06:27 AM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
This is pretty much the standard anti-choice line. "Innocent human lives"... well define "life". Do you mean a cluster of cells without the capacity for thought? Or do you mean a human being? There's a tremendous difference.
As far as I know human life starts at one point - conception.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
"He who learns must suffer. And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God." Aeschylus
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
seer is offline
seer tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 14,079
Join Date: April 20th, 2003
Spam: 13 | Anti-Spam: 4526
Pearls: 733
 
Old
  August 6th 2003 , 06:29 AM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
Actually there are Atheists for Life.
One of the most radical pro-lifers I knew was a woman and an atheist...

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
"He who learns must suffer. And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God." Aeschylus
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
WinAce is offline
WinAce Gone way too soon 1984-2005
Currently Unavailable
 
 
Posts: 587
Join Date: March 12th, 2003
Spam: 10 | Anti-Spam: 182
Pearls: 447
 
Old
  August 6th 2003 , 01:36 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
I would guess that's an indication that there are no good reasons for being anti-abortion outside from adhering to the commandments of a fundie religion... wouldn't you? Similarly, it's amazing how few non-Jews wear yarmulkes for the fashion statement alone.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
Lung transplant: $400,000. Anti-rejection drugs: $20,000 a year. Being denied the only operation that can save my life, on the grounds that it's too life-threatening: Priceless. There are some things money can't buy; health, in my case, is not one of them. Read all about it (and donate) at Save-Allan.org!
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Warcraft3 is offline
Warcraft3 You are a moron
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Other  
Posts: 3,502
Join Date: March 31st, 2003
Spam: 1613 | Anti-Spam: 1480
Pearls: 766
 
Old
  August 6th 2003 , 02:17 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
Hello WinAce:

I would guess that's an indication that there are no good reasons for being anti-abortion outside from adhering to the commandments of a fundie religion... wouldn't you?
Ummmmmmmmm no. Here is why I believe an atheist is more likely to take a pro-choice stance than a Christian is........

1. The definition of life****Since an atheist would presumably be using science as his (yes Im using the male tense here, so just eat it all you feminists) guide for the definition of life he would have a rather blurry "line in the sand" for when the embryo is truly "life". With science as the guide the exact moment isnt really cut and dry, so I could see why an atheist would be pro-choice (since pro-life excludes ALL abortion....regardless of development or lack thereof)

2. The definition of human****Again the definition according to science can be a bit blurry here as to exactly when the embryo is truly "human". We Christians believe this begins at conception, but many people disagree and believe consciousness is directly related to brain function alone.

3. Special circumstances****I have heard atheists argue from the position of practicality also. They might say that if an unwanted child is forcibly brought into this world, then it might be better for society (and maybe even the child also) if the child was never born in the first place. Kind of a "least harm principle" argument. ****Also under this category are the situations of medical complications with the pregnancy and rape. These might also contribute to someone not being pro-life.



So those are some reasons why I think an atheist might be pro-choice and not pro-life.


Similarly, it's amazing how few non-Jews wear yarmulkes for the fashion statement alone.
Sorry WinAce, this one isnt quite that simple. (Nice try though---here have a bunny ) Satire and witty comments arent enough to explain this one because it is a complex issue.



Russ

 
  Alumnus of the Month: AotM vote winner - Issue reason: November 2004 Alumnus    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
AtheistArchon is offline
AtheistArchon "Forget" the president.
Currently Unavailable
 
 
Posts: 5,130
Join Date: March 13th, 2003
Spam: 674 | Anti-Spam: 1189
Pearls: 817
 
Old
  August 6th 2003 , 02:24 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
As far as I know human life starts at one point - conception.
- And I repeat: Human life is not the same thing as a human being.

- My skin cells are "human life".

 
  Letterman: gym debate particpant - Issue reason: friend of cats    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
WinAce is offline
WinAce Gone way too soon 1984-2005
Currently Unavailable
 
 
Posts: 587
Join Date: March 12th, 2003
Spam: 10 | Anti-Spam: 182
Pearls: 447
 
Old
  August 6th 2003 , 05:51 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
Today @ 02:17 PM post located here
warcraft3:


Hello WinAce:
Hi there.

Ummmmmmmmm no. Here is why I believe an atheist is more likely to take a pro-choice stance than a Christian is........
Those are pretty much the reasons anyone would be pro-choice. For a large segment of the population, however, what they infer from an ancient text takes precedence over such reasons. Atheists (generally) have no such problem.

And I wasn't kidding about the yarmulke analogy....

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
Lung transplant: $400,000. Anti-rejection drugs: $20,000 a year. Being denied the only operation that can save my life, on the grounds that it's too life-threatening: Priceless. There are some things money can't buy; health, in my case, is not one of them. Read all about it (and donate) at Save-Allan.org!
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
seer is offline
seer tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 14,079
Join Date: April 20th, 2003
Spam: 13 | Anti-Spam: 4526
Pearls: 733
 
Old
  August 6th 2003 , 06:04 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
And I repeat: Human life is not the same thing as a human being.

- My skin cells are "human life".
That is just silly. Your skin cells are not human life.

We have two facts:

1. The fetus is alive (life).

2. And it is human (not plant,fish,mineral).

= human life. So you say it is ok to kill innocent human life?

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
"He who learns must suffer. And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God." Aeschylus
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
C. D. Ward is offline
C. D. Ward The sky is falling!!
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Humanist  |  libertarian  
Posts: 4,299
Join Date: July 8th, 2003
Spam: 3522 | Anti-Spam: 1185
Pearls: 806
 
Old
  August 6th 2003 , 07:04 PM
 
frown
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
Today @ 06:04 PM post located here
seer:


That is just silly. Your skin cells are not human life.

We have two facts:

1. The fetus is alive (life).

2. And it is human (not plant,fish,mineral).

= human life. So you say it is ok to kill innocent human life?
But by that definition, your skin cells are human life...

1. Your skin cells are alive (life)

2. And they are human (not plant, fish, mineral)

= human life. So do you exfoliate?

For the record, however, although I do not recognize a zygote or blastocyst as human life worthy of legal protection, I am generally opposed to abortion as a means of birth control. It should be primarily a procedure of medical or psychological necessity.

C. D. Ward

 
  Letterman: gym debate particpant - Issue reason: debate warrior    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
"This is my simple religion. There is no need for temples; no need for complicated philosophy. Our own brain, our own heart is our temple; the philosophy is kindness." HH Tenzing Gyatzo, the 14th Dalai Lama

"Omni mutantur, nihil interit" Ovid

"Accept the consequences of a free society, or go home and crawl under the bed where all the mean mean boogiemen can't get you." Sweet Mercury

Random Neurons Firing (my blog)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
seer is offline
seer tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 14,079
Join Date: April 20th, 2003
Spam: 13 | Anti-Spam: 4526
Pearls: 733
 
Old
  August 6th 2003 , 07:31 PM
 
In reply to this post by seer
 
 
 
For the record, however, although I do not recognize a zygote or blastocyst as human life worthy of legal protection.
Exactly,few atheist do. My point all along... Making excuses to kill innocent human life.

But by that definition, your skin cells are human life...

1. Your skin cells are alive (life)

2. And they are human (not plant, fish, mineral)

= human life. So do you exfoliate?
Then you wouldn't mind if I skinned you?

The fact is a skin cell is part of the human body, a zygote is the WHOLE human.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
"He who learns must suffer. And even in our sleep pain that cannot forget falls drop by drop upon the heart, and in our own despair, against our will, comes wisdom to us by the awful grace of God." Aeschylus
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 

« Previous Thread   |   Post New Thread   |   Next Thread »


 
Forum Jump  

Page generated in 0.62437 seconds with 14 queries