PDA

View Full Version : Contradiction Of Luke To The Scriptures


Ezraarah
April 8th 2004, 07:36 PM
Ques ; If Luke was a disciple of Yashua As you Christian Have Been Led To Believe , Then Why Are There So Many Contradictions Between The Other Gospels And The Books He Recorded ?
The Book Of Acts Was Written By Luke Who Was Never A Companion Of Yashua , But A Gentile . The Book Of Corinthians Was Written By The Deceiver Paul . Another So - Called Follower Of Yashua , Who Never Met Yashua , But Was An Avid Persecutor Of Him And His Disciples ( Acts Chapter 8 ) .

Luke saysThe Most High doesn't Dwell <> The he says 'God who dwells in his
In temples made with Heads <> Chosen temples
Acts 7 ; 48 <> ll Chronicles 7; 12 , 16
The Lord Knows the hearts of all <> The Lord test you to find out what is
Men In your heart
Acts 1 ; 24 <> Deuteronomy 13 ; 3
Sell all you have and giveAlms <> Build your family
Meaning ; sell all your belonging <> Proverbs 13 ; 22
And give the money to him
Luke 12 ; 33
Importunity ( Persistance ) in <> Repetitious prayers are condemned
Prayer is Commended <> Matthew 6 ; 7 - 8
Luke 11 ; 8 , Luke18 ; 5,7
Hate your family in order to be a <> Love one another as Jesus
Disciple of Jesus Commanded
Luke 14 ; 26 <> 1John 3 ;23
Woman are in subjection to their <> Women can prophesy
Husbands <> Acts 2 ; 18 , Acts 21 ; 9
1Peter 3;1 , lCorinthians 14; 34
If you break the law or disobey the <> All that believe have sins of the laws
Holy Spirit you are a sinner Of Moses Take away
Mark 3 ;29 <> Acts13 ; 39
Luke says satan entered into Judas <> According to John , satan entered Judas
Before the supper . During the last supper .
Luke 22 ; 3 - 4 , 7 <> John 13 ; 27
More than three woman came to the <> Just three woman came to the
Sepulicher Sepulcher says Mark
Luke 24 ; 10 <> Mark 16 ; 1
Two men stood by the Sepulcher says <> Only one man sat beside the Sepulcher
Luke Says Matthew
Luke 24 ; 4 <> Matthew 28 ; 1 - 3
Luke said that Salah was the son of <> Salah was the son of Arphaxad
Cainan Luke 3 ; 35 , 36 <> Genesis 11 ; 12
The Infant Christ was not taken into <> The Infant Christ Was Take Into
Egypt Egypt .
Luke 2 ; 22 , 39 <> Matthew 2 ; 14 -15 , 19 , 21 , 23
Christ's First Sermon Was In The Plain <> Christ Preached His First Sermon On
Luke 6 ; 17,20 <> The Mount Matthew 5 ; 1,2
Luke saysthat it was one blind man <> Matthew Reports Two Blind Men
Who Approached Jesus <> Approached Jesus
Luke18; 35,38 <> Matthew 20 ; 30
Holy Ghost Bestowed The Day Of <> Holy Ghost Bestowed Before Pentecost
Pentecost ( Acts 1 ; 8 , Acts 2 ; 14 ) <> John 20 ; 22
Luke Says The Disciple Were Instructed <> The Disciple Were Commanded To Go
To God To Jerusalem And Stay There To Galilee Immediately After The
Luke 24 ; 49 <> Resurrection Matthew28 ; 10
After The Supposed Crucifixion And <> After The Supposed Crucifixion And
Ressurection of Jesus , Luke Says The Resurrection Of Jesus Matthew Says
Jesus First Appeared In Jerusalem To Jesus First Appeared To The Eleven
The Eleven Disciples . Disciples In Galilean On A Mountain
Matthew 28 ; 16 <> Luke 24 ; 33,36,37
Luke And His Friend Paul Said The <> Abraham's Seed Did Receive The
Promised Land Never Belonged To Promised Land
Anyone Acts 7 ; 5 ; Hebrew 11 ; 9,13 <> Genesis 13 ; 14 -15 , 17 , 17 ; 8
Christ Mission Was One Of Peace <> Not So Says Matthew
Luke 2 ; 13 -14 Matthew 10 ; 34
A Good Name Is A Curse Says Luke <> A Good Name Is A Blessing
Luke 6 ; 26 Ecclesiastes 7; 1 , Proverbs 22 ; 1
Abraham Bought Land For Sepulchers <> Jacob Purchased It Says Joshua ,
Acts 7 ; 16 Joshua 24 ; 32
Ques ; How Do You Believe The Writings Of A Man That Contradicts Himself ?
Luke Contradicts Himself In The Following Verse ;
In One Verse He Says Christ Ascended From Mount Olivet .
Acts 1; , 12 <>
And when he had spoken these things while they beheld , he
Was taken up ; And a cloud received him out of their sight ,
Then returned they unto Jerusalem from The Mount Called
Olivet , which from Jerusalem A Sabbath Days Journey
Then He Says '' No '' , He Says '' I Mean From Bethany
Luke 22 ; 50 - 51 <>
And one of them smote the servant of the high priest and cut
Off his right ear and Jesus answered and said , suffer ye thus
Far and he touched his ear , and healed him ''
Luke ( Of Course ) Tells Paul's Vision , He Says ;
- The men heard a voice and stood speechless ( Acts 9 ; 7 )
- The men saw a light , but heard no voice ( Acts 22 ; 9 )
- No , they all heard a voice ( Acts 26 ; 16 )
What It All Boils Down To Is This ; Luke Wrote The Book Of Acts To Verify The Deceiver Paul '' Calling '' Three Time Read It ! Its In Your Bible In Black And White !!! Lukes Words Are Not To Be Trusted !! He Was Not Only The Last To Write His Opinion Of What Took Place During Jesus Ministry , He Was Never Present At Any Of The Evens He Wrote About . In Fact , The Book Of Acts , Which Was Authored By Luke , WAS WRITTEN 28 YEARS AFTER THE ALLEGED CRUCIFIXION AND EVEN THE BOOK ENTITLED LUKE WAS WRITTEN 25 YEARS AFTERWARDS , LUKE WAS ONLY INTERESTED IN THE FAME AND RECOGNITION OF HILSELF AND HIS PRINE OPPORTUNITY ARRIVED WITH HIS FRIEND PAUL'S CLAIM TO APOSTESHIP AND EVENTUAL INCLUSION OF THE GENTILES TO THE COVENANT CAN'T YOU CHRISTIAN SEE ? The Foundation Your Church Is Built On Is Like The House That Was Built In Sand
( Matthew 7 ; 26 - 27 )

Hanna222
April 8th 2004, 10:34 PM
Ques ; If Luke was a disciple of Yashua As you Christian Have Been Led To Believe , Then Why Are There So Many Contradictions Between The Other Gospels And The Books He Recorded ?
The Book Of Acts Was Written By Luke Who Was Never A Companion Of Yashua , But A Gentile . The Book Of Corinthians Was Written By The Deceiver Paul . Another So - Called Follower Of Yashua , Who Never Met Yashua , But Was An Avid Persecutor Of Him And His Disciples ( Acts Chapter 8 ) .

Luke saysThe Most High doesn't Dwell <> The he says 'God who dwells in his
In temples made with Heads <> Chosen temples
Acts 7 ; 48 <> ll Chronicles 7; 12 , 16
The Lord Knows the hearts of all <> The Lord test you to find out what is
Men In your heart
Acts 1 ; 24 <> Deuteronomy 13 ; 3
Sell all you have and giveAlms <> Build your family
Meaning ; sell all your belonging <> Proverbs 13 ; 22
And give the money to him
Luke 12 ; 33
Importunity ( Persistance ) in <> Repetitious prayers are condemned
Prayer is Commended <> Matthew 6 ; 7 - 8
Luke 11 ; 8 , Luke18 ; 5,7
Hate your family in order to be a <> Love one another as Jesus
Disciple of Jesus Commanded
Luke 14 ; 26 <> 1John 3 ;23
Woman are in subjection to their <> Women can prophesy
Husbands <> Acts 2 ; 18 , Acts 21 ; 9
1Peter 3;1 , lCorinthians 14; 34
If you break the law or disobey the <> All that believe have sins of the laws
Holy Spirit you are a sinner Of Moses Take away
Mark 3 ;29 <> Acts13 ; 39
Luke says satan entered into Judas <> According to John , satan entered Judas
Before the supper . During the last supper .
Luke 22 ; 3 - 4 , 7 <> John 13 ; 27
More than three woman came to the <> Just three woman came to the
Sepulicher Sepulcher says Mark
Luke 24 ; 10 <> Mark 16 ; 1
Two men stood by the Sepulcher says <> Only one man sat beside the Sepulcher
Luke Says Matthew
Luke 24 ; 4 <> Matthew 28 ; 1 - 3
Luke said that Salah was the son of <> Salah was the son of Arphaxad
Cainan Luke 3 ; 35 , 36 <> Genesis 11 ; 12
The Infant Christ was not taken into <> The Infant Christ Was Take Into
Egypt Egypt .
Luke 2 ; 22 , 39 <> Matthew 2 ; 14 -15 , 19 , 21 , 23
Christ's First Sermon Was In The Plain <> Christ Preached His First Sermon On
Luke 6 ; 17,20 <> The Mount Matthew 5 ; 1,2
Luke saysthat it was one blind man <> Matthew Reports Two Blind Men
Who Approached Jesus <> Approached Jesus
Luke18; 35,38 <> Matthew 20 ; 30
Holy Ghost Bestowed The Day Of <> Holy Ghost Bestowed Before Pentecost
Pentecost ( Acts 1 ; 8 , Acts 2 ; 14 ) <> John 20 ; 22
Luke Says The Disciple Were Instructed <> The Disciple Were Commanded To Go
To God To Jerusalem And Stay There To Galilee Immediately After The
Luke 24 ; 49 <> Resurrection Matthew28 ; 10
After The Supposed Crucifixion And <> After The Supposed Crucifixion And
Ressurection of Jesus , Luke Says The Resurrection Of Jesus Matthew Says
Jesus First Appeared In Jerusalem To Jesus First Appeared To The Eleven
The Eleven Disciples . Disciples In Galilean On A Mountain
Matthew 28 ; 16 <> Luke 24 ; 33,36,37
Luke And His Friend Paul Said The <> Abraham's Seed Did Receive The
Promised Land Never Belonged To Promised Land
Anyone Acts 7 ; 5 ; Hebrew 11 ; 9,13 <> Genesis 13 ; 14 -15 , 17 , 17 ; 8
Christ Mission Was One Of Peace <> Not So Says Matthew
Luke 2 ; 13 -14 Matthew 10 ; 34
A Good Name Is A Curse Says Luke <> A Good Name Is A Blessing
Luke 6 ; 26 Ecclesiastes 7; 1 , Proverbs 22 ; 1
Abraham Bought Land For Sepulchers <> Jacob Purchased It Says Joshua ,
Acts 7 ; 16 Joshua 24 ; 32
Ques ; How Do You Believe The Writings Of A Man That Contradicts Himself ?
Luke Contradicts Himself In The Following Verse ;
In One Verse He Says Christ Ascended From Mount Olivet .
Acts 1; , 12 <>
And when he had spoken these things while they beheld , he
Was taken up ; And a cloud received him out of their sight ,
Then returned they unto Jerusalem from The Mount Called
Olivet , which from Jerusalem A Sabbath Days Journey
Then He Says '' No '' , He Says '' I Mean From Bethany
Luke 22 ; 50 - 51 <>
And one of them smote the servant of the high priest and cut
Off his right ear and Jesus answered and said , suffer ye thus
Far and he touched his ear , and healed him ''
Luke ( Of Course ) Tells Paul's Vision , He Says ;
- The men heard a voice and stood speechless ( Acts 9 ; 7 )
- The men saw a light , but heard no voice ( Acts 22 ; 9 )
- No , they all heard a voice ( Acts 26 ; 16 )
What It All Boils Down To Is This ; Luke Wrote The Book Of Acts To Verify The Deceiver Paul '' Calling '' Three Time Read It ! Its In Your Bible In Black And White !!! Lukes Words Are Not To Be Trusted !! He Was Not Only The Last To Write His Opinion Of What Took Place During Jesus Ministry , He Was Never Present At Any Of The Evens He Wrote About . In Fact , The Book Of Acts , Which Was Authored By Luke , WAS WRITTEN 28 YEARS AFTER THE ALLEGED CRUCIFIXION AND EVEN THE BOOK ENTITLED LUKE WAS WRITTEN 25 YEARS AFTERWARDS , LUKE WAS ONLY INTERESTED IN THE FAME AND RECOGNITION OF HILSELF AND HIS PRINE OPPORTUNITY ARRIVED WITH HIS FRIEND PAUL'S CLAIM TO APOSTESHIP AND EVENTUAL INCLUSION OF THE GENTILES TO THE COVENANT CAN'T YOU CHRISTIAN SEE ? The Foundation Your Church Is Built On Is Like The House That Was Built In Sand
( Matthew 7 ; 26 - 27 )




:pray: you need another hug (((((((((((((((((EZ)))))))))))Jesus loves YOU and so do I:smile:

djconklin
April 10th 2004, 05:00 AM
1) Luke never claimed to be an eyewitness to all of the events that wererecorded in his book. As he explicitly states in his prolougue (vs, 1-3) he is recording what eyewitnesses had seen and others had recorded.

2) There is NO evidence that Luke wrote his gospel 28 years after the events; there is internal indicators that point to its having been written before the fall of Jerusalem and there is evidence that the book of Acts was written shortly before 62-4 A.D. when Peter and Paul were killed.

According to early church tradition 'the brother whose praise is in the gospel' of 2 Corinthians 8:18, written in 56 A.D. is Luke (Wenham, John Redating Matthew, Mark and Luke: A Fresh Assault on the Synoptic Problem. (IVP, 1992): pages 230-1). This would mean that Luke had to have been written prior to 55 A.D. to allow sufficient time for the gospel to have been written and distributed.

Gaston, ( Lloyd No Stone on Another: Studies in the Significance of the Fall of Jerusalem in the Synoptic Gospels. Supplements to Novum Testamentum, Vol 13. (Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1970): page 245) reports that A.M. Perry's work on Luke (The Sources of Luke's Passion-Narrative. (1920)) led Perry to the conclusion that Luke was written about A.D. 45. This would coincide with the prologue to Theophylact's Commentary that says Luke wrote fifteen years after the Ascension. (Hengel, Martin Studies in the Gospel of Mark. Trans. by John Bowden (Philadelphia: Fortress, 1985)
page 6)

3) There is NO evidence that Luke wrote for "FAME AND RECOGNITION".