There is no such thing as a former Christian. - Page 3 - TheologyWeb Campus
TheologyWeb Campus TheologyWeb Campus


Hello and welcome to TheologyWeb – theology debate with a serious dose of fun! It has been our goal to create one of the best and most innovative discussion sites on the Net. Please visit our forums where we debate and discuss everything from religion, politics, lifestyle, pop culture, to who is the coolest member of the moderating team. Register now and join in the fun, its free, easy, and makes Dee Dee Warren happy.




*This site is best viewed in Mozilla Firefox with a minimum display resolution of 1024x768.

Reply

There is no such thing as a former Christian.
View First Unread
Jedidiah is online now
Jedidiah TheologyWeb Grandfather
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 7,288
Join Date: August 1st, 2003
Spam: 9918 | Anti-Spam: 277
Pearls: 574
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:14 PM
 
In reply to this post by Moksha
 
 
 
I presume you take that understanding from Paul?
That may be his understanding but it's not mine nor many other ex-christians experience.
I am afraid I don't clearly understand your second comment here. Are youone of the "ex-christians?

I take my understanding from all of the New Testament together.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
He has showed you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Jedidiah is online now
Jedidiah TheologyWeb Grandfather
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 7,288
Join Date: August 1st, 2003
Spam: 9918 | Anti-Spam: 277
Pearls: 574
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:17 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jaecp
 
 
 
There are plenty of former christians, theological claims that we were never really christians accomplishes what Jeb?
Sorry I missed this when I first read your post. What ii accomplishes is clearing up a misconception on the part of ex Christians.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
He has showed you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Jedidiah is online now
Jedidiah TheologyWeb Grandfather
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 7,288
Join Date: August 1st, 2003
Spam: 9918 | Anti-Spam: 277
Pearls: 574
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:20 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
Believers, if you would like to discuss this I would be agreeable to following you to another thread for that purpose. As I said before my interest is to discuss this with so-called ex Christians. So far I have not had anything except the phony no-true-"scotsman" business.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
He has showed you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
themuzicman is offline
themuzicman Are they flying yet?
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 36,699
Join Date: March 6th, 2003
Spam: 43745 | Anti-Spam: 6060
Pearls: 658
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:22 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
I am afraid I don't clearly understand your second comment here. Are youone of the "ex-christians?

I take my understanding from all of the New Testament together.
Insert obligatory discussion of Hebrews 6, here.

There is simply no way that one has been enlightened and have been made partakers of the Holy Spirit and tasted the heavenly gift, and not been a Christian. This entire section is about the Jewish Christians, who should be mature and well grounded in their faith, still struggling with the elementary principles of Christianity and whether the Old Covenant Law was to be followed.

And this portion is a warning to them: They have been enlightened, they have partaken of the Holy Spirit (to the 1C church, this was salvation), and tasted the heavenly gift.

If they fall away it is impossible for them to return. Not because it is impossible to fall away, but because Christ is not crucified again.

"Again" here means that there would need to be a second crucifixion. Which means that they embraced the first one.

Thus, it is obvious to conclude that:

1) The author of Hebrews is speaking of those who were saved, who
2) have fallen away, and
3) Cannot return.

And in context, this is a warning passage, which means the author is directing a very real warning to the Jews not to return to the Old Covenant and salvation by works.

Thus, there are ex-Christians.

Michael

 
  Department Head: is somewhat mighty! - Issue reason: looking for flying pigs Alumnus of the Month: AotM vote winner - Issue reason: June 2008 Alumnus Letterman: gym debate particpant - Issue reason: debate warrior    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
The Rental Car Review!
Open Theists! Join your Facebook group!
Blue Blood Republicans are losers.
Obama - One Bad Apple Mistake, America
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
JAYMZ is offline
JAYMZ tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 827
Join Date: January 24th, 2009
Spam: 0 | Anti-Spam: 156
Pearls: 210
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:39 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
Also to add, did these " former " christians repent and try to turn away from sin, in response to believing in Christ.
Or did they just say " I believe in the gospel " and keep on living their lives the same way as before.

 
    tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Jaecp is online now
Jaecp Servant of Necoho
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  JEDI!  |  Jadiestic  
Posts: 1,795
Join Date: May 15th, 2008
Spam: 0 | Anti-Spam: 793
Pearls: 210
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:39 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
What misconceptions?

This is, as has been said, nothing more than a No True Scotsman argument, and a rationalization for why you can ignore apostates.

 
    tWebber  
     
In the name of all that is good and holy O Jaecp, we ask that you henceforth write your posts in English, for the sake of the ignorant. -ApologiaPhoenix
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Serafina is offline
Serafina Pole vaults with scissors
Currently Unavailable
 
Female  |  Buddhism  |  Libertarian  
Posts: 515
Join Date: December 6th, 2007
Spam: 0 | Anti-Spam: 103
Pearls: 265
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:41 PM
 
In reply to this post by JAYMZ
 
 
 
Also to add, did these " former " christians repent and try to turn away from sin, in response to believing in Christ.
Or did they just say " I believe in the gospel " and keep on living their lives the same way as before.
I know both kinds.

 
    Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
SlapShot is offline
SlapShot tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Undisclosed  |  Mountain  |  Hideaway  
Posts: 252
Join Date: January 7th, 2007
Spam: 14 | Anti-Spam: 21
Pearls: 480
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 04:42 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
Last edited by SlapShot : September 17th 2009 at 04:51 PM .  
 
 
Jedidiah, you've called ex-christians "so-called" christians, and implied there is a specific definition for a true christian. Please give us that definition of the true christian, and the reason you think ex-christians are phoney.
Over the past few years I've viewed Tweb I've read that catholics, protestants, mormons, jehovah's witnesses, ect aren't true christians. Please pick one or more of any one of the 33,000 plus christian groups you think are true christians.

 
    Quiner Member tWebber  
     
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Seasanctuary is offline
Seasanctuary Magna Cum Laude
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Agnostic  |  Independent  
Posts: 8,346
Join Date: December 30th, 2003
Spam: 467 | Anti-Spam: 1824
Pearls: 530
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 06:19 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
Misses the mark. A Christian trusts the Gospel, not just believes it is true.
Feel free to add that to the list, and anything else necessary to pass your "correct verbal formulation" test.

 
  Alumnus of the Month: AotM vote winner - Issue reason: September 2004 Alumnus    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
seanD is online now
seanD tWebber
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Independent  
Posts: 2,631
Join Date: December 25th, 2008
Spam: 3 | Anti-Spam: 1773
Pearls: 270
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 07:35 PM
 
In reply to this post by SlapShot
 
 
 
Jedidiah, you've called ex-christians "so-called" christians, and implied there is a specific definition for a true christian. Please give us that definition of the true christian, and the reason you think ex-christians are phoney.
As a Christian, you never ever stop developing and learning -- because there are so many areas to learn -- and the two go hand in hand. But there's actually a point that you reach, a threshold, where you no longer have any doubt whatsoever, and you know you could never turn away regardless of what challenge is presented. This is not "forced willpower" to believe, but a genuine depth perception that is solely based on knowledge and experience.

My point is, anytime I hear an apostate on here argue their case against Christianity (and this is epitomized when I read or listen to arguments from apostates like Dan Barker), the Christian knowledge they display is really really basic stuff, typically erroneous in many cases, and they usually confuse their Christian experience with Christian knowledge. Maybe this is more a Christian problem than proving they were never actually Christian, but this tells me they never followed the basic principles of being a true Christian, that is, constantly pursuing truth through God's word -- in other words, taking their beliefs seriously and vigorously researching it in all areas of the subject -- history, theology, archeology, etc.

 
    tWebber  
     
beyondtradition

What does it mean when Christians side with atheists to attack other Christians who defend the bible, and use rabid personal attacks and insults to do it, all in the name of protecting a secular dogma? Something is terribly amiss.
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Jedidiah is online now
Jedidiah TheologyWeb Grandfather
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 7,288
Join Date: August 1st, 2003
Spam: 9918 | Anti-Spam: 277
Pearls: 574
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 07:38 PM
 
 
 
 
And in context, this is a warning passage, which means the author is directing a very real warning to the Jews not to return to the Old Covenant and salvation by works.

Thus, there are ex-Christians.

Michael
The author continues after his tirade against these folks you think are ex Crhistians by saying, "But, beloved, we are convinced of better things concerning you, and things that accompany salvation, though we are speaking in this way."

Thus, there are no ex-Christians

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
He has showed you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Jedidiah is online now
Jedidiah TheologyWeb Grandfather
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 7,288
Join Date: August 1st, 2003
Spam: 9918 | Anti-Spam: 277
Pearls: 574
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 07:39 PM
 
In reply to this post by Serafina
 
 
 
I know both kinds.
I doubt it.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
He has showed you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Jedidiah is online now
Jedidiah TheologyWeb Grandfather
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Conservative  
Posts: 7,288
Join Date: August 1st, 2003
Spam: 9918 | Anti-Spam: 277
Pearls: 574
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 07:44 PM
 
 
 
 
Feel free to add that to the list, and anything else necessary to pass your "correct verbal formulation" test.
The problem is there is no verbal formulation. Plus you are in effect saying that whatever I say, you know someone who meets the requirements. Why should I pay any attention to an argument like that?

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
He has showed you, O man, what is good. And what does the LORD require of you? To act justly and to love mercy and to walk humbly with your God. (Micah 6:8)
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Seasanctuary is offline
Seasanctuary Magna Cum Laude
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Agnostic  |  Independent  
Posts: 8,346
Join Date: December 30th, 2003
Spam: 467 | Anti-Spam: 1824
Pearls: 530
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 09:59 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
The problem is there is no verbal formulation. Plus you are in effect saying that whatever I say, you know someone who meets the requirements. Why should I pay any attention to an argument like that?
I suspect most of the Christians around here would not have identified the same problem you picked out. It's like when Gerry asked, "What is the core concept of God among Christians?"

I already had the feeling that no matter how I answered you would come up with some reason why anyone who was a real Christian would have worded it differently. But I answered it straight and honestly anyway. The picky response was a confirmation.

 
  Alumnus of the Month: AotM vote winner - Issue reason: September 2004 Alumnus    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
Moksha is offline
Moksha poltergeist
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Quaker  |  Dystopian  
Posts: 228
Join Date: May 6th, 2009
Spam: 413 | Anti-Spam: 14
Pearls: 200
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 10:12 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
I am afraid I don't clearly understand your second comment here. Are you one of the "ex-christians?
No I'm not one of the "ex-christians". I'm one of the ex-christians.
I take my understanding from all of the New Testament together.
I take mine from experience.

 
    tWebber  
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 
guacamole is offline
guacamole in molcajete
Currently Unavailable
 
Male  |  Christian  |  Centrifugal  
Posts: 3,842
Join Date: January 21st, 2004
Spam: 2917 | Anti-Spam: 1651
Pearls: 531
 
Old
  September 17th 2009 , 11:37 PM
 
In reply to this post by Jedidiah
 
 
 
Geez. It's not a point of metaphysics, i's a point of self-identification. It's not a statment of theology, its a statement of practice. A person who is an ex-Christian no longer identifies as a Christian and no longer practices Christianity. Religion is complicated enough. Don't make it harder than it has to be.

 
    Charter Member Quiner Member tWebber  
     
Which way shall I fly
Infinite wrath and infinite despair?
Which way I fly is hell; myself am hell;
And in the lowest deep a lower deep,
Still threat’ning to devour me, opens wide,
To which the hell I suffer seems a heaven.
Paradise Lost. Book iv. Line 73.
 
 
  Reply With Quote
Click Here for Post Options
 

The following tWebber says Amen to guacamole for this useful Post:

« Previous Thread   |   Post New Thread   |   Next Thread »


 
Forum Jump  

Page generated in 0.56258 seconds with 15 queries